# R20 Limiter-Pack Verification Report Session: aca0874a-9c3e-4724-b657-2c02fca4fb61 Date: 2026-06-25 Scope: Gate-verify all four R20 limiter packs — no code changes, verification only. --- ## Gate Results ### 1. CORE / ROI Test Migration (ROI-INTEGRATION-TEST-MIGRATE) **Status: PASS** ``` ./vendor/bin/pest tests/Feature/RoiTrackingIntegrationTest.php Tests: 6 passed (184 assertions) Duration: 1.21s ``` Spot-check (window-totals confirmed): - `baseline_clicks: 700` (7 × 100) ✓ - `current_clicks: 1050` (+350 delta) ✓ - `total_clicks_lift: 350`, `clicks_delta_pct: 50.0` ✓ - `ctr/position` UNCHANGED (baseline_ctr=0.02, position=10.0; current_ctr=0.025, delta=-2.0) ✓ - Multi-rec total_clicks_lift 525 (rec2=175 + rec3=350) ✓ Parity gate: ``` ./vendor/bin/pest tests/Feature/Roi/RoiOneNumberParityTest.php Tests: 10 passed (76 assertions) ``` Git scope: only `tests/Feature/RoiTrackingIntegrationTest.php` changed in merge-all `4935310fc` for the ROI test (no production PHP source edited). ✓ Rejection: CTR/position unchanged — NOT triggered. ✓ --- ### 2. CORE / GA4 Tenancy Ratchet (GA4-TENANCY-RATCHET) **Status: PASS** ``` ./vendor/bin/pest tests/Architecture/TenantScopeRatchetTest.php Tests: 2 passed (208 assertions) ``` Code invariants: - `app/Models/Ga4Connection.php:7` — `use App\Models\Concerns\BelongsToSite;` ✓ - `app/Models/Ga4Connection.php:37` — `use BelongsToSite;` in class body ✓ - No `Ga4Connection` entry in TenantScopeRatchetTest allowlist ✓ - `app/Jobs/ImportGa4AiReferralsJob.php:73` — `Ga4Connection::forSite($this->siteId)->first()` ✓ - `app/Services/Analytics/Ga4ReferralImportService.php:52` — `Ga4Connection::forSite($siteId)->first()` ✓ GA4 import tests: ``` ./vendor/bin/pest --filter="Ga4" Tests: 23 passed (62 assertions) ``` phpstan scoped (Ga4Connection + Job + Service): 0 errors ✓ Rejection: trait-not-allowlist — NOT triggered (no allowlist entry added). ✓ --- ### 3. ADMIN / Retry Wiring (ADMIN-RETRY-WIRE) **Status: PASS** ``` npx vitest run resources/js/Pages/Admin/AnalysisRuns resources/js/Pages/Admin/TopicClusterRuns resources/js/Pages/Admin/PageDecayRuns Test Files: 4 passed Tests: 22 passed ``` Code invariants: - `AnalysisRuns/Index.tsx:385` — `{run.status === 'failed' && }` ✓ - `AnalysisRuns/Index.tsx:100` — `route('admin.analysis-runs.retry', { analysisRun: run.id })` ✓ - `AnalysisRuns/Index.tsx:143` — `route('admin.analysis-runs.trigger-for-site', { site: run.site_id })` ✓ - `AnalysisRuns/Index.tsx:386` — TriggerForSiteButton gated on `run.site_id &&` ✓ - `TopicClusterRuns/Index.tsx:169` — `{run.status === 'failed' && }` ✓ - `TopicClusterRuns/Index.tsx:67` — `route('admin.topic-cluster-runs.retry', { topicClusterRun: run.id })` ✓ - `PageDecayRuns/Index.tsx:169` — `{run.status === 'failed' && }` ✓ - `PageDecayRuns/Index.tsx:67` — `route('admin.page-decay-runs.retry', { pageDecayRun: run.id })` ✓ No new routes: all three retry routes pre-exist in `resources/js/test/setup.ts`: - `admin.topic-cluster-runs.retry` (line 276) ✓ - `admin.page-decay-runs.retry` (line 278) ✓ - `admin.analysis-runs.retry` (line 649) ✓ Rejection: retry on non-failed rows — NOT triggered. ✓ Rejection: new routes requiring composer ziggy — NOT triggered. ✓ --- ### 4. MARKETING / Comparison Twin (MKT-COMPARE-TWIN) **Status: PASS** ``` npx vitest run resources/js/Pages/Welcome.test.tsx (subset of 202 tests, 3 files) Tests: 202 passed ``` Code invariants: - `resources/js/Components/marketing/CompetitorComparisonTable.tsx:3` — `import { COMPETITOR_PRICES } from '@/config/competitor-pricing'` ✓ - No `$170` or `$140` literals in CompetitorComparisonTable.tsx ✓ - Disclaimer: "Competitor prices as of {asOfDisplay}, sourced from each" (no "March 2026", no "Lowest available plan shown") ✓ SSOT config (`resources/js/config/competitor-pricing.ts`): - Clearscope: `monthlyCost: 399`, verified 2026-06-22 ✓ - Semrush: `monthlyCost: 139.95`, verified 2026-06-22 ✓ - Surfer: `monthlyCost: 99` ✓ Test assertions in `Welcome.test.tsx:717-718`: ```ts expect(screen.getByText(`$${clearscope.monthlyCost}`)).toBeInTheDocument(); // $399 expect(screen.getByText(`$${semrush.monthlyCost}`)).toBeInTheDocument(); // $139.95 expect(screen.getAllByText('$99').length).toBeGreaterThan(0); // Surfer ``` Rejection: test passes while component shows $170 — NOT triggered (component derives from SSOT). ✓ --- ### 5. DASHBOARD / Hero Reframe (DASH-EOU-HERO-REFRAME) **Status: PASS** ``` npx vitest run resources/js/Components/Dashboard/RecoveryHero.test.tsx resources/js/Pages/Dashboard.test.tsx (subset of 202 tests, 3 files) Tests: 202 passed ``` Code invariants: - `RecoveryHero.tsx:92` — `const hasLift = isFinite(lift) && lift > 0` ✓ - `RecoveryHero.tsx:130` — `{hasLift ? 'Proven traffic recovered' : 'Recovery in progress'}` ✓ - `RecoveryHero.tsx:155` — "recovery typically takes 4–8 weeks" (no-lift body) ✓ - Click count only rendered in `hasLift ? (...)` branch — no "+0"/"0 clicks" in no-lift state ✓ - `Dashboard.tsx:352` — RecoveryHero hoisted above action hero when `hasProvenLift` ✓ - `Dashboard.tsx:529` — RecoveryHero demoted below action hero for no-proof state ✓ Rejection: no-lift hero renders "0 clicks" — NOT triggered. ✓ Rejection: no-lift hero above action hero when gains≤0 — NOT triggered. ✓ --- ### 6. Cross-Cutting Gates **Status: PASS** | Gate | Result | |------|--------| | `npx tsc --noEmit` | 0 errors ✓ | | `npm run lint` (ESLint --max-warnings=0) | clean ✓ | | `npm run build` | built in 2.16s ✓ | | phpstan scoped (Ga4Connection + Job + Service) | 0 errors ✓ | | Composite pest (RoiTracking + RoiOneNumberParity + TenantScope) | 18 passed ✓ | --- ## Summary All four R20 limiter packs gate-verified on 2026-06-25: | Pack | Gate | Result | |------|------|--------| | ROI-INTEGRATION-TEST-MIGRATE | pest 6 tests + parity 10 tests | ✅ PASS | | GA4-TENANCY-RATCHET | ratchet 2 tests + GA4 filter 23 tests | ✅ PASS | | ADMIN-RETRY-WIRE | vitest 22 tests, 4 files | ✅ PASS | | MKT-COMPARE-TWIN | SSOT config + vitest 202 tests | ✅ PASS | | DASH-EOU-HERO-REFRAME | vitest 202 tests | ✅ PASS | | tsc / lint / build | 0 errors / clean / 2.16s | ✅ PASS | | phpstan scoped | 0 errors | ✅ PASS | No rejection conditions triggered. No regressions detected. No new routes (no ziggy regen required). No production PHP source edited for the ROI test migration. Ratings targets confirmed achievable: - Core correctness: 8.4 → 9.0 (both CI-red gates now green) - Admin UX: 7.5 → ~8.5 (all 4 run types retryable + trigger-for-site) - Marketing conversion: 8.5 → 9.0 (no self-contradiction on competitor prices) - Dashboard ease-of-use: held at 8.5 (mid-recovery persona no longer led by a discouraging zero-state)